5 Possible Solutions to “the Grandfather Paradox”
I’ve written multiple pieces about contemporary paradoxes in physics and philosophy in my previous stories. Paradoxes, in simple and straightforward terms, are those statements or situations that completely confuse your understanding of things, creating contradictions. While paradoxes can be disruptive to conventional understanding, they also open up new avenues for research and have significant implications for discovery. In this short piece, I will briefly discuss the well-known Grandfather paradox and its possible solutions.
It’s important to note that there is no definite solution to the paradox and any attempts at solving it are subject to varying degrees of debate. Before we delve into the solutions, let’s first get a quick understanding of what the paradox is about.
What’s the paradox?
The Grandfather paradox is a well-known paradox in the field of time travel that has been debated and discussed for over a century. It refers to the logical contradiction that arises
“If a person goes back in time and murders their grandfather, causing their father’s non-existence and therefore their own birth to never occur.”
It raises many questions about the nature of time, the possibility of time travel, and the laws of physics like whether it is possible to go back in time and change events in the past, and if so, what the implications of those changes would be or on the consistency of the past and the stability of the present, as well as the relationship between cause and effect. Essentially, the Grandfather Paradox forces us to confront the logical and philosophical problems that arise when we try to imagine the possibility of time travel.
The origins of the Grandfather paradox can be traced back to the early 20th century, when science fiction writers first began exploring the idea of time travel. It has been a topic of discussion and debate primarily among scientists, philosophers, and science fiction writers, who have proposed various solutions to the paradox. Despite its long history, the paradox remains an open question and one of the most enduring and thought-provoking paradoxes in the history of science.
Possible Solutions and Interpretations
Novikov’s self-consistency principle
This principle was proposed by Russian physicist Igor Novikov in the 1980s. It states that the laws of physics do not allow for any action that would create a paradox. This means that
if a time traveler were to go back in time and try to alter events in a way that would create a paradox, the laws of physics would prevent that from happening.
The principle is based on the idea that the universe has a certain degree of self-consistency, and that events must unfold in a way that does not result in a contradiction.
Parallel universes (Many World’s Interpretation)
This solution to the Grandfather paradox involves the idea of parallel universes, which suggests that there may be multiple, parallel versions of reality. According to this theory, time travel would create a new, parallel universe in which the paradoxical event could occur without affecting the original timeline. This idea was first proposed by physicist Hugh Everett in the 1950s and is known as the “many-worlds interpretation” of quantum mechanics.
Block time theory
This theory, also known as the “block universe” theory, asserts that time is like a block, and events are fixed and unchangeable. In this case, it would not be possible to change the past and create a paradox. The idea of block time has its roots in the philosophy of determinism, which holds that
the future is predetermined and that all events, including the actions of time travelers, are predetermined and cannot be altered.
Temporal Logic
Temporal logic is a branch of mathematical logic that is concerned with the reasoning about time. Some argue that the grandfather paradox can be resolved through a careful application of temporal logic, which allows for the logical analysis of events occurring at different times. Temporal logic provides a framework for reasoning about the relationships between events and the constraints that must be satisfied in order to avoid a paradox.
Deterministic universe
This solution to the Grandfather paradox is based on the idea of determinism, which asserts that the universe is deterministic and that all events, including the existence of time travelers and their actions, are predetermined and cannot be altered. According to this theory,
the Grandfather paradox cannot occur because the actions of the time traveler are already predetermined and cannot be altered.
All these solutions or better say, approaches to the solution, are still highly debated. The paradox remains an open question in the field of both physics and philosophy of science. There’s a really fascinating video by minute physics about it and I highly recommend you to watch it in order to understand it in more detail.
Thank you so much for reading. If you liked this story don’t forget to press that clap icon as many times as you want. If you like my works and want to support me then you can become a medium member by using this link or Buy me a coffee ☕️. Keep following for more such stories.
